REPOSITORY > RESULTS

Doctoral dissertation

Ageing of zirconia ceramics for dental applications

Author(s): Anastasia Samodurova (Author), Tomaž Kosmač (Supervisor), Andraž Kocjan (Co-Supervisor)

Thesis defense date: 20.11.2015

Organization: MPŠ - Mednarodna podiplomska šola Jožefa Stefana

PID: 20.500.12556/ReVIS-15066

Views: 0 | Downloads: 0

Abstract

This doctoral thesis deals with the kinetics and mechanisms of hydrothermal ageing of 3 mol % yttria-doped tetragonal zirconia polycrystalline (3Y-TZP) ceramic, which is an attractive material for dental restorations due to its unique combination of excellent mechanical properties, biocompatibility and aesthetic appearance. The tetragonal grains in sintered ceramic are thermodynamically metastable and can be transformed to a monoclinic form by an externally applied stress, thereby developing transformation toughening. On the other hand, the metastability of the tetragonal phase makes 3Y-TZP ceramics susceptible to spontaneous tetragonal-to-monoclinic (t–m) transformation in humid environments at slightly elevated temperatures (~ 30-300 °C), i.e. to the so-called low-temperature degradation (LTD) or ageing. This process is accompanied by intensive microcracking in the transformed zone that may ultimately lead to the degradation of mechanical properties and thereby preventing a use of 3Y-TZP in dental applications. The LTD in 3Y–TZP is mainly affected by the grain size and can be further influenced by doping with alumina or some other oxides, such as ceria, silica, etc.
In my work I focussed on the role of silica or/and alumina-(co)-doping in the nucleation and propagation of the hydrothermally induced t-m transformation. In order to differentiate between the distinct contributions of the two dopants to the overall resistance to ageing, the specimens were prepared by infiltration of silica sol into pre-sintered, porous 3Y-TZP discs, which where alumina-free or contained 0.05 and 0.25 wt. % of alumina. The infiltration technique was chosen for co-doping, since it could be easily included in the already established computer-aided design and computer-aided manufacturing machining (CAD/CAM) procedure commonly used in the production of 3Y-TZP dental restorations. After the final sintering, the specimens were characterized in terms of their microstructure, phase composition, mechanical properties and accelerated ageing behaviour. Kinetics of the LTD was studied by quantifying the transformed monoclinic fraction from X-ray diffraction analysis as well as by analysing cross sections of the aged samples by optical microscopy. The sub-surfaces of the aged samples were studied using focused ion beam–scanning electron microscopy analysis. In order to gain a better inside into the possible mechanism associated with the deceleration of LTD by co-doping, selected as-sintered samples were additionally examined by Raman and impedance spectroscopy. Coupled-diffusion experiments were carried out in order to assess the reactivity in in the 3Y-TZP-SiO2 and 3Y-TZP-SiO2-Al2O3 systems.
The results showed that the grain size was not a prevailing factor influencing the ageing resistance of 3Y-TZP ceramics that were sintered in the temperature range of 1400-1500 °C. The microstructures of all these materials were practically identical, being unimodal and exhibiting similar grain size and size distribution. However, the LTD stability was substantially improved by single-doping and even more by co-doping. The presence of alumina increases the grain boundary cohesion, which was reflected in an increased fraction of transgranular fracture and reduced microcracking upon the moisture-induced t–m transformation. The presence of individual alumina grains commonly observed in SEM micrographs of sintered silica-free 3Y-TZP, containing 0.25 wt. % of alumina, indicates a very low solubility of the dopant being restricted to the grain boundary area reflecting in ~100-400 orders of magnitude higher grain boundary resistivity, compared to the bulk resistivity. In silica-doped and alumina/silica co-doped ceramics sintered at temperatures ≤ 1500 °C an amorphous silica-rich phase was preferentially located at the multiple grain junctions, causing the rounding of zirconia grains and reducing the internal stresses. Silica does not affect the fracture mode, but it substantially reduces the microcracking upon ageing.
The increase of sintering temperatures to 1550-1600 °C resulted in substantial differences in the microstructure, phase partitioning and LTD behaviour of undoped, single-doped and co-doped materials. The addition of alumina enhances the grain growth, but still decelerates the hydrothermal ageing of 3Y-TZP. In contrast, silica-doped 3Y-TZP sintered at higher temperatures (≥ 1500 °C) aged much faster compared to alumina-doped materials. This temperature-related change in the ageing behaviour coincides with the formation of yttria-rich silicate phase in Y2O3-SiO2 system at temperatures ≥1500 °C, leading to the depletion of yttria from the tetragonal grains. In the presence of alumina the diffusion of yttria into the silica phase was prevented, implying that alumina has an impact on the composition and properties of the glassy phase in silica-doped 3Y-TZP.
In high-temperature (≥ 1550 °C) sintered alumina/silica co-doped 3Y-TZP the penetration of silica phase from triple grain junctions along the grain boundaries was observed accompanied by sudden emergence of larger yttria-rich, untransformable, t`-ZrO2 grains within the matrix of small t grains with a lower yttria concentration. The overall partitioning process was the slowest in co-doped material, leaving the higher amount of yttria in tetragonal grains, making them more resistant towards transformation and thereby decelerating the LTD. No alumina grains could be found in co-doped material, even when it was sintered at higher temperatures, indicating that a larger amount of alumina can be dissolved in co-doped 3Y-TZP. This will additionally stabilize the t-grains.
The alumina/silica co-doping of 3Y-TZP ceramic thus resulted in higher amount of yttria and alumina in tetragonal grains. Higher thermodynamic stability of these grains together with the presence of silica phase at triple grain junctions or/and grain boundaries, led to exceptionally improved LTD resistance of 3Y-TZP, without compromising its strength and fracture toughness.

Attachments

Cite this work