Views: 4 | Downloads: 0
The aim of the present thesis was to investigate the contribution of thermal and non-thermal factors to the perception of thermal comfort, and thus on behavioural temperature regulation. This was evaluated in four separate studies, each addressing specific factors, potentially affecting the thermal comfort.
Common to the main studies of the thesis (Studies 1 to 4) is the methodology used to determine the range of skin temperatures considered within the comfort zone. The characteristics of the thermal comfort zone (TCZ) in these studies were assessed with a water-perfused suit (WPS). Subjects donned the WPS, in which the temperature of the water perfusing the suit changed in a sinusoidal manner from 10° to 50°C. Subjects were instructed to maintain the temperature of the suit within a thermally comfortable range by depressing a switch. Over the 1-hr period of each trial, the temperature of the water perfusing the suit described a damped oscillation due to the subjects’ regulation of thermal comfort. The width of this damped temperature oscillation was defined as the TCZ.
Study 1 tested the hypothesis that hypoxia alters the boundary temperatures of the thermal comfort zone, and that exercise training modifies any hypoxia-induced alterations. Fourteen healthy men were confined for 10 days in normobaric hypoxia, the fraction of oxygen (FO2) in the air being maintained at 0.139 ± 0.003. Subjects were randomly assigned to either a Live High (LH) group, which did not conduct any exercise during the 10-d exposure (N=6), or a Live High-Train High (LH-TH) group, which conducted two bouts of exercise daily (N=8), each comprising 60-min cycle exercise at 50% of their pre-determined, hypoxic peak power output. A subset of participants also completed a control trial in normobaric normoxia (Control; N=5). Behavioural thermoregulation was assessed in the Control group under normoxic conditions and in the LH and LH-TH groups after 24-h and 216-h of confinement in hypoxia. The upper and lower temperatures of the thermal comfort zone were determined with WPS described above. Skin temperatures and proximal-distal skin temperature gradients (2 sites: forearm-fingertip, calf-toe) were recorded at minute intervals during the trials. There were no significant differences in the characteristics of the TCZ between the LH and LH-TH groups, and no difference between the Control, 24-h and 216-h hypoxic exposures. Long-term exposure to normobaric hypoxia does not affect the boundary temperatures of the TCZ, nor its magnitude.
Study 2 investigated separate and combined effects of inactivity and hypoxia (target altitude of 4000m) on behavioural temperature regulation in 11 healthy normothermic young male subjects. Subjects participated in three 21-day interventions separated by at least three months: 1) Hypoxic ambulatory confinement (HAMB; fraction of oxygen in the inhaled gas, FiO2=0.141 ± 0.004; partial pressure of oxygen in the inspired gas, PiO2=90.0 ± 0.4; ~4000 m simulated altitude), 2) Hypoxic bedrest (HBR; FiO2=0.141 ± 0.004; PiO2=90.0 ± 0.4; ~4000 m simulated altitude), and 3) Normoxic bedrest (NBR; FiO2=0.209; PiO2=133.1 ± 0.3). During each experimental campaign, measurements were performed 5 days prior to the intervention (D-5), and on days 10 (D10) and 20 (D20) of the intervention. No statistically significant differences were found in any of the characteristics of the TCZ between the interventions (HAMB, HBR and NBR), or between different measurement days (D-5, D10, D20) within each intervention. Rectal temperature remained stable, whereas skin temperature (Tsk) increased in all experimental conditions throughout the one hour trial. No differences in Tsk between D-5, D10 and D20 and between HAMB, HBR and NBR were revealed. Subjects perceived the regulated temperature as thermally comfortable, and neutral or warm. Regulation of thermal comfort is not compromised by hypoxic inactivity.
Study 3 As part of a study investigating the effect of nonthermal factors (i.e. hypoxia and inactivity) on temperature regulation, subjects were required to conduct three trials over a period of one year. It has been reported that the seasonal variation in length of day and light intensity can affect the circadian rhythm as well as some characteristics of temperature regulation. We investigated the characteristics of the TCZ during two seasons. Twelve subjects participated in three trials conducted in October 2012 (T1), April 2013 (T2) and October 2013 (T3). We monitored skin and rectal temperature at a minute intervals and recorded subjects’ ratings of thermal comfort and thermal sensation every 10 min. TCZ varied from 6.0 °C in T1, to 8.3 °C in T2 and 11.4 °C in T3, the difference between T1 and T3 being significantly different. The differences observed in the thermal perception between T1 and T3 were for trials conducted during the same season. We conclude that perception of thermal comfort does not seem to be affected by the seasonal variation, when comparing the data obtained in spring and autumn as in the present study.
Study 4 evaluated regional thermal comfort in males (N=8) and females (N=8). Subjects were requested to regulate the temperature of the water delivered to a water-perfused suit, such that it was thermally comfortable. In separate trials, subjects regulated the temperature of the whole suit, or specific regions of the suit covering different skin areas. The TCZ was determined for the whole body, and for the following regions: arms, legs, front torso, back torso, hands, feet, and head. The range of regulated temperatures did not differ between genders and skin regions. Females maintained higher mean skin temperature (Tsk) during the legs (females: 35.2 ± 0.7°C, males: 34.6 ± 0.8°C; p<0.05) and whole body (females: 35.1 ± 0.4°C, males: 34.3 ± 0.6°C; p<0.01) temperature regulation (TR), compared to males, who showed greater variation in preferred temperature for these areas. Females perceived thermal comfort at a higher mean Tsk during the legs and whole body TR.
Study 5 (in Appendix D) demonstrates the importance of including assessment of thermal comfort perception when evaluating protective clothing for extreme environments. The study evaluated the efficiency of two heat dissipation strategies under simulated desert patrol missions. Ten males participated in four trials, during which they walked on a treadmill (45°C, 20% relative humidity), carrying a load of 35 kg; two 50-min walks were separated by a 20-min rest. Active cooling (AC) provided by reduced clothing in combination with a ventilated vest was compared with passive cooling (PC), achieved by reduced clothing combined with partly undressing, water spraying and fanning body suThe aim of the present thesis was to investigate the contribution of thermal and non-thermal factors to the perception of thermal comfort, and thus on behavioural temperature regulation. This was evaluated in four separate studies, each addressing specific factors, potentially affecting the thermal comfort.
Common to the main studies of the thesis (Studies 1 to 4) is the methodology used to determine the range of skin temperatures considered within the comfort zone. The characteristics of the thermal comfort zone (TCZ) in these studies were assessed with a water-perfused suit (WPS). Subjects donned the WPS, in which the temperature of the water perfusing the suit changed in a sinusoidal manner from 10° to 50°C. Subjects were instructed to maintain the temperature of the suit within a thermally comfortable range by depressing a switch. Over the 1-hr period of each trial, the temperature of the water perfusing the suit described a damped oscillation due to the subjects’ regulation of thermal comfort. The width of this damped temperature oscillation was defined as the TCZ.
Study 1 tested the hypothesis that hypoxia alters the boundary temperatures of the thermal comfort zone, and that exercise training modifies any hypoxia-induced alterations. Fourteen healthy men were confined for 10 days in normobaric hypoxia, the fraction of oxygen (FO2) in the air being maintained at 0.139 ± 0.003. Subjects were randomly assigned to either a Live High (LH) group, which did not conduct any exercise during the 10-d exposure (N=6), or a Live High-Train High (LH-TH) group, which conducted two bouts of exercise daily (N=8), each comprising 60-min cycle exercise at 50% of their pre-determined, hypoxic peak power output. A subset of participants also completed a control trial in normobaric normoxia (Control; N=5). Behavioural thermoregulation was assessed in the Control group under normoxic conditions and in the LH and LH-TH groups after 24-h and 216-h of confinement in hypoxia. The upper and lower temperatures of the thermal comfort zone were determined with WPS described above. Skin temperatures and proximal-distal skin temperature gradients (2 sites: forearm-fingertip, calf-toe) were recorded at minute intervals during the trials. There were no significant differences in the characteristics of the TCZ between the LH and LH-TH groups, and no difference between the Control, 24-h and 216-h hypoxic exposures. Long-term exposure to normobaric hypoxia does not affect the boundary temperatures of the TCZ, nor its magnitude.
Study 2 investigated separate and combined effects of inactivity and hypoxia (target altitude of 4000m) on behavioural temperature regulation in 11 healthy normothermic young male subjects. Subjects participated in three 21-day interventions separated by at least three months: 1) Hypoxic ambulatory confinement (HAMB; fraction of oxygen in the inhaled gas, FiO2=0.141 ± 0.004; partial pressure of oxygen in the inspired gas, PiO2=90.0 ± 0.4; ~4000 m simulated altitude), 2) Hypoxic bedrest (HBR; FiO2=0.141 ± 0.004; PiO2=90.0 ± 0.4; ~4000 m simulated altitude), and 3) Normoxic bedrest (NBR; FiO2=0.209; PiO2=133.1 ± 0.3). During each experimental campaign, measurements were performed 5 days prior to the intervention (D-5), and on days 10 (D10) and 20 (D20) of the intervention. No statistically significant differences were found in any of the characteristics of the TCZ between the interventions (HAMB, HBR and NBR), or between different measurement days (D-5, D10, D20) within each intervention. Rectal temperature remained stable, whereas skin temperature (Tsk) increased in all experimental conditions throughout the one hour trial. No differences in Tsk between D-5, D10 and D20 and between HAMB, HBR and NBR were revealed. Subjects perceived the regulated temperature as thermally comfortable, and neutral or warm. Regulation of thermal comfort is not compromised by hypoxic inactivity.
Study 3 As part of a study investigating the effect of nonthermal factors (i.e. hypoxia and inactivity) on temperature regulation, subjects were required to conduct three trials over a period of one year. It has been reported that the seasonal variation in length of day and light intensity can affect the circadian rhythm as well as some characteristics of temperature regulation. We investigated the characteristics of the TCZ during two seasons. Twelve subjects participated in three trials conducted in October 2012 (T1), April 2013 (T2) and October 2013 (T3). We monitored skin and rectal temperature at a minute intervals and recorded subjects’ ratings of thermal comfort and thermal sensation every 10 min. TCZ varied from 6.0 °C in T1, to 8.3 °C in T2 and 11.4 °C in T3, the difference between T1 and T3 being significantly different. The differences observed in the thermal perception between T1 and T3 were for trials conducted during the same season. We conclude that perception of thermal comfort does not seem to be affected by the seasonal variation, when comparing the data obtained in spring and autumn as in the present study.
Study 4 evaluated regional thermal comfort in males (N=8) and females (N=8). Subjects were requested to regulate the temperature of the water delivered to a water-perfused suit, such that it was thermally comfortable. In separate trials, subjects regulated the temperature of the whole suit, or specific regions of the suit covering different skin areas. The TCZ was determined for the whole body, and for the following regions: arms, legs, front torso, back torso, hands, feet, and head. The range of regulated temperatures did not differ between genders and skin regions. Females maintained higher mean skin temperature (Tsk) during the legs (females: 35.2 ± 0.7°C, males: 34.6 ± 0.8°C; p<0.05) and whole body (females: 35.1 ± 0.4°C, males: 34.3 ± 0.6°C; p<0.01) temperature regulation (TR), compared to males, who showed greater variation in preferred temperature for these areas. Females perceived thermal comfort at a higher mean Tsk during the legs and whole body TR.
Study 5 (in Appendix D) demonstrates the importance of including assessment of thermal comfort perception when evaluating protective clothing for extreme environments. The study evaluated the efficiency of two heat dissipation strategies under simulated desert patrol missions. Ten males participated in four trials, during which they walked on a treadmill (45°C, 20% relative humidity), carrying a load of 35 kg; two 50-min walks were separated by a 20-min rest. Active cooling (AC) provided by reduced clothing in combination with a ventilated vest was compared with passive cooling (PC), achieved by reduced clothing combined with partly undressing, water spraying and fanning body surfaces during the rest. Cooling strategies were compared to naked condition (NC) and full protective equipment (FP) with no supplemental cooling. During the walks, skin temperature (Tsk) was lower and heat flux (Q) higher in AC, whereas during the rest, Q was greater in PC. Tsk was higher during NC, compared to other conditions. In the FP, rectal temperature and heart rate were higher than in other conditions. Subjects perceived the ambient temperature as warmer and reported about greater thermal and wear discomfort during FP, compared to other conditions. Cooling strategies substantially improved evaporative cooling, and thus subjects’ thermal status and thermal comfort. Four subjects terminated the trial prematurely due to signs of heat exhaustion in the FP condition.
rfaces during the rest. Cooling strategies were compared to naked condition (NC) and full protective equipment (FP) with no supplemental cooling. During the walks, skin temperature (Tsk) was lower and heat flux (Q) higher in AC, whereas during the rest, Q was greater in PC. Tsk was higher during NC, compared to other conditions. In the FP, rectal temperature and heart rate were higher than in other conditions. Subjects perceived the ambient temperature as warmer and reported about greater thermal and wear discomfort during FP, compared to other conditions. Cooling strategies substantially improved evaporative cooling, and thus subjects’ thermal status and thermal comfort. Four subjects terminated the trial prematurely due to signs of heat exhaustion in the FP condition.