Views: 6 | Downloads: 0
Fluorine is one of the most abundant elements in the earth’s crust, and as such is an inevitable part of a person’s life. Fluorine, in the form of fluoride, is used in prevention of dental caries. The adequate intake (AI) of fluorine from all sources is set at 0,05 mg day–1 kg body weight; this intake is recommended for all ages over 6 months because that high intakes are associated with no known, unwanted health effects; development of dental fluorosis in children or skeletal fluorosis in both children and adults. There is a narrow margin between beneficial and harmful effect; dental fluorosis was observed even at daily intakes lower (0.03–0.04 mg kg–1) or a little higher (0.05–0.07 mg kg–1) than AI. Major sources of fluorine for humans are drinking water, beverages and dentifrices. Daily intake from food can be also of concern. In some environments, especially in industry districts, some other anthropogenic sources are of concern.
Tea is one of the beverages, which can contain higher fluorine contents. Tea plant (Camellia sinensis) is the only plant known to take up fluorine from the soil and accumulate it in the leaves, from where it is easily released, in the form of fluoride, during infusion. Contribution of tea to the daily fluorine intake can be therefore significant. Fluorine levels in tea leaves and fluoride levels of tea infusions of some commercially available teas in Slovenia were determined. Fluorine levels were 53–435 mg kg–1, while fluoride levels of tea infusions ranged between 0.31 and 3.55 mg l–1. There were no significant differences in leaching efficacies of fluorine between black, oolong and green teas; efficacies, as determined for continuous and repeated infusions, were 55–90 % and 74–100 %, respectively. Leaching efficacy of fluorine from pu’erh tea was significantly lower; 21–38 % for continuous infusions and 37–59 % for repeated infusions. Consumption of five tea cups (1000 ml) represents 9–101 % of daily AI (fr an adult person weighting 70 kg). If to this also intake from food is added, 25–175 % daily AI in nonfluoridated and 35–210 % of daily AI in fluoridated areas can be reached. Chronic exposure to that high fluorine levels can be already associated with fluorine related health effects.
Slovenians are known as consumers of higher amounts of herbal teas. Fluorine contents in some commercially available herbal teas and their infusions were determined. The contents of fluorine determined were, with the exception of chamomile (29 mg kg–1), nettle (16 mg kg–1), hibiscus (13 mg kg–1) and mint (12 mg kg–1), lower than fluorine contents in most plants (< 10 mg kg–1). Although different leaching efficacies of fluorine were observed (12–89 %), fluoride levels in tea infusions were not higher than 5.2 mg l–1, which makes a contribution to the daily intake of fluorine minor.
In view of the increased fluorine contents, in particular in chamomile and nettle, it was decided to investigate, whether any herbs used for preparing tea infusions can uptake higher quantities of fluorine. Surrounding of aluminum smelter Talum d. d. near Kidričevo was chosen as experimental environment. Necrotic changes of the maize typical for injuries caused by gaseous fluorides were observed in autumn of 2005 in the surrounding of Talum d. d. Determined fluorine levels in male flowers heads and in the leaves were significantly higher than allowed contents of fluorine in animal fodder (30 mg kg–1). The study was continued in the year 2010 with the aim to investigate the influence of fluorine in the soil on the contents of fluorine in plants. For this purpose the samples of the soil, maize leaves and of tea herbs grown in the vicinity of Talum d. d. were taken. Samples from uncontaminated environment were also obtained. The contents of fluorine determined in maize laves were significantly lower than in 2005, but at the same time significantly higher than in the samples from uncontaminated environment (14–28 mg kg–1 vs. 6–9 mg kg–1). This testifies that necrotic changes of the maize, as observed in the year 2005, were caused by uncontrolled release of gaseous fluorides and also that the maize is able to take up some fluorine from the soil.
The contents of fluorine determined in herbs from the vicinity of Talum d. d. showed increased contents of fluorine in nettle; the contents of fluorine determined in the nettle grown in the area of the dominant wind were significantly higher than contrary to dominant wind direction, 71–100 mg kg–1 and 10–28 mg kg–1, respectively. Fluorine contents in the nettle have been shown to be dependent mostly on fluoride contents in the soil and on wind direction, while fluorine contents in the soil and its pH have smaller effect.
In view of the increased contents of fluorine determined in commercially available nettle tea, and in nettle grown in the vicinity of Talum d. d., it was decided to investigate accumulation properties of the nettle for fluorine. Accumulation properties were studied in a pot experiment; nettles were left grown on commercially available substrate contaminated with addition of ammonium fluoride (0–600 mg NH4F kg–1 substrate), which provided a source of fluorine in the form of fluoride. The effect of NH4F to the pH of the substrate and to the fluoride contents of substrate were monitored. Morphological changes of the nettles, stress syndrome response of the plants and the impact of added NH4F to the masses of roots, stems and leaves were observed. Accumulation of fluorine in roots, leaves and stems were also examined. Changes in fluoride contents of the substrate and its pH in the dependence on the NH4F contents of substrates can be best described by sigmoidal fit.
There were no statistically significant differences in pH values between samples and controls, while fluoride levels of substrates where nettles were grown, were statistically significantly lower (8–22 %) than of controls (substrates without plants), which can be explained by uptake of fluoride from the substrate by nettles.
The contents of fluorine in the nettle were 19-times higher than fluorine levels in most plants. The higher levels were determined in leaves (110–235 mg kg–1 vs. 54–158 μg plant–1), followed by roots (60–217 mg kg–1 vs. 24–122 μg plant–1) and stems (5–43 mg kg–1 vs. 4–14 μg plant–1). Both, masses and contents of fluorine in leaves, stems and roots, can be with respect to the NH4F contents of the substrate, fitted to the polynomial function of degree three.
The ability of the nettle to grow and flower (and to multiply) together with bioaccumulation factor higher than 4.7 and translocation factor higher than 1.4, through the entire investigated treatment range of substrate with NH4F, testify that nettle is fluorine accumulator, which can be used as a passive fluorine bioindicator. An estimation of phytoremediation potential discovered that nettle has a promising potential in fitoremediation of fluoride polluted soil according to the mechanism of fitoextraction. As estimated, by using nettle, it is possible to remove from the top layer of soil (≈ 20 cm) of 1 ha between 0.36 and 0.77 kg of fluoride in only 75 days. This is higher than are usual the lowest contents of fluoride in the soil (≈ 0.13 kg) and 4.6–9.9 % of the highest contents of fluoride (≈ 7.8 kg) in the top layer of soil.