Views: 0 | Downloads: 0
The thesis addresses a challenge in decision analysis that deals with risk and uncertainty as well as automation of decision support in this context.
The problem is motivated by complex decision making problems that encounter risk and uncertainty, requiring risk analysis during the decision making process. The starting point is risk analysis and common risk analysis approaches, i.e., ex-ante and ex-post approaches, which have been identified with certain limitations and potential for improvement in the context of automating decision support. On the one hand, ex-ante is a prospective approach that evaluates the potential risk at the beginning of the period in question and tries to describe the state of the world at the end of that period by using projection, simulation or foresight approaches. It is heavily based on information about the state of the world that is clearly known but incomplete and, on a basic level, does not consider the level of certainty of that information. On the other hand, ex-post is a retrospective approach that evaluates risk at the end of the period in question, by considering the real (observed) state of the world. Therefore, the former approach relies on incomplete or imperfect information, whereas the latter has at its disposal complete pieces of information. In a real-world problem, making a decision at the beginning of the period of interest is of higher priority and in some cases is the only solution, so the ex-post approach is not suitable. To improve the ex-ante approach by considering additional ('what is certainly known') information with quantified low uncertainty, we propose an integration of predictive and diagnostic models that introduce a predictive and a diagnostic layer in the scope of the ex-ante approach, respectively.
The second point of motivation is the evaluation of alternatives in accordance with a state of the world that would take place when a corresponding alternative is realized. Traditional methodologies for decision modeling do not explicitly offer the possibility to consider the state of the world in the evaluation of alternatives. The work presented in the thesis allows individuals to express preferences over an outcome of an alternative and a state of the world upon application of an alternative.
Furthermore, existing approaches to decision analysis require many steps to be executed and a wide range of tools to be used for each of them. However, having a decision support tool or a system that can handle most of these simultaneously is highly desirable. Therefore, we propose a methodological framework for decision analysis that connects all required steps and delivers the desired support. The proposed methodological framework deals with decision making under risk and uncertainty and consists of two modules: risk assessment and risk management. The risk assessment module implements the proposed extended ex-ante approach to risk evaluation. The risk management module uses a set of predefined functions to produce the desired support.
The proposed methodological framework is applied in a case-study scenario from the domain of surface and ground water protection from phytochemicals used in agriculture. The outcome of the case-study is a decision support system with a web-based interface. Extensive performance evaluation of both modules of the methodological framework's implementation is performed using data collected on agricultural fields that are part of an experimental site located in Western France. The resulting decision support system considers a description of a particular application of pesticides on a field as input, and proposes a set of agricultural practices to be performed on the field, in order to avoid surface and ground water pollution with phytochemicals.