REPOSITORY > RESULTS

Doctoral dissertation

Models of batch process control software

Author(s): Giovanni Godena (Author), Stanko Strmčnik (Supervisor)

Thesis defense date: 15.06.2016

Organization: MPŠ - Mednarodna podiplomska šola Jožefa Stefana

PID: 20.500.12556/ReVIS-15044

Views: 4 | Downloads: 0

Abstract

Beside the undoubted benefits brought into the batch-process control systems by the introduction of the standard ISA-88 and the tools based on it, there are also some problems concerning the standard and the related tools. In the dissertation, we focus on the following three problems. The first problem comes from the recipe system, which is rather demanding for the operators due to its complex abstraction. The second problem lies in the unsatisfactory management of the complexity of batch procedures development due to the too simple behaviour model of these procedures. The third problem in our concern is the too high level of repetition of information in the recipes and in their too low reusability. This problem stems from the too low abstraction level of equipment and procedural control object model.
In the dissertation, we proceed from the hypothesis that it is possible to concieve new models of the batch-process control software, which will alleviate the operators’ work, simplify the implementation of the control procedures, and reduce the repetition of information in the recipes and increase their reuse.
In the work, we first introduce batch processes and their control software. We explain the motivation for introducing the ISA-88 standard and present its overview, with the emphasis on its three models, namely the process model, the physical model, and the procedural control model, as well as the relations between them. In the following we describe the difficulties in using the ISA-88 standard and point out three of them that we consider the most troubling and that we try to resolve in the dissertation.
The first topic we deal with in the core part of the dissertation is the recipes abstraction. We begin with the analysis of the actual abstraction as defined by the ISA-88 standard and implemented in tools based on the standard. In the analysis, we point out some difficulties in the implementation and the use of this abstraction. Then we present our proposition for a new recipe abstraction based on a tabular notation of the recipes. In the sequel, we give a more detailed presentation of the new abstraction. We start with the definition of the mapping from the classical recipe notation to the tabular notation. Then we present the algorithm for executing the tabular recipes and point out some limitations of the tabular recipe notation compared to the classical notation. Finally, we present the mechanisms for controlling the execution flow of the tabular recipes, which stem from the tabular structure of the recipes.
The next topic we deal with is the behaviour model of the elementary entities of procedural control. We begin with an overview of state machine based abstractions. Then we analyze the actual phase behaviour model, as defined by the ISA-88 standard, and as implemented and documented in a prototype tool for batch process control. The analysis shows some deficiencies of the actual phase behaviour model, namely in its representation in the standard and in the tool documentation, as well as in its very structure. In the following, we present a proposition for a new phase behaviour model, which renders it possible to get rid of the stated deficiencies, and we give a thorough description of the new model. Finally, the phase behaviour modeling using the new model is illustrated on an example from a real industrial project.
The last topic we deal with is the object model of equipment and procedural control. First, we state that the current model, as defined by the ISA-88 standard and implemented in the related batch process control tools, fails in avoiding the repetition of information in the recipes and in assuring a high degree of recipes reuse. Then we present an idea that a possible solution to these problems could be in the introduction of a more sophisticated object model, based on a concept of multiple inheritance, i.e. on overlapping equipment classes. In the sequel, we give a detailed description of the object model of equipment and procedural control, including its implementation in a home-developed batch-process control tool. We illustrate the use of a new concept by means of a real industrial case study, performed on a resin-synthesis batch-process control system. Finally, we present results of a validation of the new concept, which shows that the new approach assures a significant improvement in avoiding the repetition of information in the recipes and increasing the degree of their reuse.

Attachments

Cite this work