REPOSITORY > RESULTS

Doctoral dissertation

Ultrasound cavitation erosion of limescale on metal surfaces

Author(s): Boštjan Pečnik (Author), Brane Širok (Supervisor), Marko Hočevar (Co-Supervisor)

Thesis defense date: 14.09.2016

Organization: MPŠ - Mednarodna podiplomska šola Jožefa Stefana

PID: 20.500.12556/ReVIS-15032

Views: 3 | Downloads: 0

Abstract

The build-up of CaCO3 (lime) scale is an operational problem which affects a range of industrial processes including membrane filtration (desalination), drilling and especially those that involve heat transfer. In heat exchangers the effects are twofold: firstly, even a thin scale coating can significantly reduce heat transfer efficiency and secondly, by acting as an insulator, it may cause heating elements to internally overheat, leading to component failure. Consequently, this leads to increased operating and maintenance costs, as well as a larger negative impact on the environment.
Currently, the most effective method of scaling prevention is by using different chemicals. However, such chemicals are costly and can cause a negative environmental impact. Ultrasonic cavitation is one of the possible alternative approaches. It is a hydrodynamic process of rapid formation, oscillation, growth and collapse of cavitation bubbles as a result of excitation of the liquid by ultrasonic acoustic waves. In this thesis, we have further examined the effect of cavitation on limescale coated surfaces.
Experimental measurements of ultrasonically induced cavitation below the sonotrode were carried out in a transparent chamber filled with distilled water. Using the high-speed imaging data, pressure fluctuations were calculated by a computer-aided algorithm based on the Brennen’s theory of cavitation cloud kinematics and a modified version of the Rayleigh-Plesset equation. Reference measurements of the pressure pulsations were conducted by a hydrophone installed at the bottom of the chamber. The analysis of cavitation structure dynamics was complemented by calculation of velocity fields from the imaging data. The results indicate a strong correlation between the fields of velocity and pressure fluctuations during the growth and collapse of cavitation structures. A comparison of pressure time series and power spectra demonstrates that our cavitation analysis method is in a good agreement with results of reference measurement methods. This way, an experimental tool was formed for prediction of pressure fluctuations in the region near the limescale deposit, with possible applications to other engineering problems.
By developing an experimental method for monitoring of cavitation phenomena, we were able to study the mechanism of scale deposit destruction on exposed metallic surfaces. For the purpose of our study, specimens were prepared in form of round-shaped steel substrates with different surface roughness, to which limescale was deposited under controlled conditions. Scale deposition was performed on a specially designed experimental set-up under operating conditions which resembled those in real industrial appliances prone to scale build-up. In the second phase of the experiment, the specimens were exposed to ultrasonic cavitation, induced by oscillations of an ultrasonic probe (sonotrode). The sonotrode, which resonated at a constant frequency, was operated at different power levels – excitation amplitudes. The progress of scale erosion was monitored by macro photography of specimens and by measurement of pressure fluctuations in the near field. During the phase of experimental data postprocessing, phenomenological relations between the sonotrode excitation power and pressure pulsation intensity in the region near the deposited scale layer were investigated, and a strong correlation between these two parameters was determined. A correct sample preparation and knowledge of the local pressure pulsations near the specimen surface meant the conditions were met for conduction of the experiment, which resulted in an assessment of scale deposit cavitation erosion.
The results have shown the intensity of cavitation erosion to be proportional to the sonotrode voltage, and consequently to the intensity of pressure fluctuations. The cavitation erosion also depends on the surface roughness of steel substrate surfaces, to which the scale was deposited. By performing an additional experiment, it was found that the descaling process can be intensified by reducing the substrate surface roughness. The scale destruction mechanism was found to largely depend on the microstructure of the scale deposit, as local inhomogeneities may intensify the erosion rate by affecting the scale adhesion on the micro and macro scale. The overall durability of limescale deposits depends on the scale surface hardness, the presence of local inhomogeneities in scale microstructure, and the substrate surface finish. These factors determine the mechanism of scale removal, which can occur either as layer by layer erosion, or by breakage of larger areas. A typical parameter to describe the topography of partly and fully eroded scale deposits is the edge length-to-area ratio of descaled surfaces. In all of the observed cases, this ratio decreases with cavitation time, leading to a gradual reduction in descaling efficiency.
The above-mentioned research results have been published in four papers in scientific journals with a good impact factor. Since the doctoral thesis has dealt with limescale accumulation and removal, which is a relevant and significant industrial problem, a wide range of industries may benefit from the new knowledge about this process. For the same reason, there is also a strong incentive to continue with the research work, especially in the field of scaling prevention methods.

Attachments

Cite this work